Our Top Meal Replacement Shakes of 2021 – Meal Replacement Shakes Our Top Meal Replacement Shakes of 2021 – Meal Replacement Shakes

Our Top Meal Replacement Shakes of 2021

We researched and compared some of the top meal replacement shake companies out there. Compare shakes below and select the right one for you.

This site is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison features to consumers in the diet shake market. It's a place people can chat & share their experiences. If you find this site useful please use the links we provide here. The affiliate referral revenue we get is how fund this site. Thank you and welcome to DietShake-Reviews. (Full Disclaimer)

#1

310 Shake®

Per Serving1 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.43 7.5/10
Our Rating:
9.1/10
A
See Rating Details

310 ShakeRating Details

Per Serving1 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.43 7.5/10

1Nutritional information from https://310nutrition.com/products/shake_vanilla. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $68.00 for 310 Vanilla with 28 servings per package. Accessed 5/22/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving2 Our Rating
Calories: 130 8.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 8g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 7g 6.8/10
Protein: 22g 7.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.32 7.5/10
Our Rating:
8.9/10
See Rating Details

Garden of LifeRating Details

Per Serving2 Our Rating
Calories: 130 8.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 8g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 7g 6.8/10
Protein: 22g 7.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.32 7.5/10

2Nutritional information from https://www.gardenoflife.com/catalog/product/view/sku/658010116022. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $64.99 for 28-servings of Vanilla Protein Powder. Accessed 8/2/19.

Per Serving3 Our Rating
Calories: 124 8.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 3g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 1.5g 5.5/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.00 8.5/10
Our Rating:
8.7/10
See Rating Details

1UP ProteinRating Details

Per Serving3 Our Rating
Calories: 124 8.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 3g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 1.5g 5.5/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.00 8.5/10

3Nutritional information from https://1upnutrition.com/collections/protein-powders/products/1up-natural-vegan-protein. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $49.99 for 1UP Organic Chocolate with 25 servings per package. Accessed 10/21/20.

Per Serving4 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 5g 5.0/10
Carbs: 10g 8.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 6g 8.5/10
Protein: 20g 9.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $3.50 5.5/10
Our Rating:
8.6/10
--
See Rating Details

Vega One ShakeRating Details

Per Serving4 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 5g 5.0/10
Carbs: 10g 8.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 6g 8.5/10
Protein: 20g 9.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $3.50 5.5/10

4Nutritional information from https://myvega.com/products/categories/powders/vega-one-shake?option_Flavor=French%20Vanilla. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $69.99 for Vega One with 20 servings per package. Accessed 7/22/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving5 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2.5g 7.5/10
Carbs: 4g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 2g 5.5/10
Protein: 17g 8.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: No 4/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.29 7.5/10
Our Rating:
8.5/10
C-
See Rating Details

Teami ProteinRating Details

Per Serving5 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 2.5g 7.5/10
Carbs: 4g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 2g 5.5/10
Protein: 17g 8.0/10
Organic: Yes 10/10
Superfoods: No 4/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.29 7.5/10

5Nutritional information from https://www.teamiblends.com/products/plant-based-protein-powder. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $31.99 for Organic Plant-Based Wellness Protein, Rich Chocolate with 14 servings per package. Accessed 6.10/20.

Per Serving6 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 10mg 9.0/10
Fat: 4g 6.0/10
Carbs: 3g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.95 8.5/10
Our Rating:
8.4/10
B+
See Rating Details

Perfect KETORating Details

Per Serving6 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 10mg 9.0/10
Fat: 4g 6.0/10
Carbs: 3g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.95 8.5/10

6https://shop.perfectketo.com/collections/all-perfect-keto-products/products/keto-whey-protein?variant=15895432396871. Accessed 5/30/19. BBB Rating accessed 5/30/19.

#7

Keto Chow®

Per Serving7 Our Rating
Calories: 123 8.5/10
Sugar: .8g 10/10
Cholesterol: 12mg 9.0/10
Fat: .5g 9.5/10
Carbs: 6.7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5.9g 8.5/10
Protein: 26g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $3.33 6.0/10
Our Rating:
8.3/10
See Rating Details

Keto ChowRating Details

Per Serving7 Our Rating
Calories: 123 8.5/10
Sugar: .8g 10/10
Cholesterol: 12mg 9.0/10
Fat: .5g 9.5/10
Carbs: 6.7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5.9g 8.5/10
Protein: 26g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $3.33 6.0/10

7Nutritional information from https://shop.ketochow.xyz/collections/keto-chow-meals-sweet-flavors/products/keto-chow-vanilla. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $70.00 for vanilla with 21 servings per package. Accessed 10/14/20.

Per Serving8 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 2g 9.5/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 9g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.55 7.5/10
Our Rating:
8.0/10
A+
See Rating Details

Thrive ShakeRating Details

Per Serving8 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 2g 9.5/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 9g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.55 7.5/10

8Nutritional information from https://media.le-vel.com/Documents/THRV002.pdf. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $40.80 for Thrive Vanilla Lifestyle Mix with 16 servings per package. Accessed 5/22/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving9 Our Rating
Calories: 90 10/10
Sugar: 3g 9.0/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 8g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 8g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.25 7/10
Our Rating:
8.0/10
A+
See Rating Details

Unico GeminiRating Details

Per Serving9 Our Rating
Calories: 90 10/10
Sugar: 3g 9.0/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 8g 9.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 8g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.25 7/10

9Nutritional information from https://uniconutrition.com/shop/gemini-organic-vegan-meal-replacement-shake. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $54.00 for Gemini Organic Vegan Meal Replacement Shake with 24 servings per package. Accessed 2/1/17."

#10

Shakeology®

Per Serving10 Our Rating
Calories: 130 8.5/10
Sugar: 7g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 16g 8.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $4.33 4.0/10
Our Rating:
7.8/10
A-
See Rating Details

ShakeologyRating Details

Per Serving10 Our Rating
Calories: 130 8.5/10
Sugar: 7g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 2g 8.0/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 16g 8.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $4.33 4.0/10

10Nutrition information taken from http://www.shakeology.com/shake-flavors#vanilla. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $129.95 for the Vanilla Shakeology® with 30 servings per package. Accessed 2/1/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving11 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 4g 6/10
Cholesterol: 3mg 9.5/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 2g 5.5/10
Protein: 17g 8.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.93 8.5/10
Our Rating:
7.8/10
B
See Rating Details

Lady Boss LeanRating Details

Per Serving11 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 4g 6/10
Cholesterol: 3mg 9.5/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 2g 5.5/10
Protein: 17g 8.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.93 8.5/10

11Nutritional information from https://ladyboss.com/lean. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $57.95 for LadyBoss LEAN Protein Shake with 30 servings per package. Accessed 9/5/18. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

#12

Ka’Chava®

Per Serving12 Our Rating
Calories: 240 5/10
Sugar: 6g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 7g 4/10
Carbs: 24g 6/10
Dietary Fiber: 9g 10/10
Protein: 25g 10/10
Organic: No 4/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $4.66 4/10
Our Rating:
7.5/10
See Rating Details

Ka’ChavaRating Details

Per Serving12 Our Rating
Calories: 240 5/10
Sugar: 6g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 7g 4/10
Carbs: 24g 6/10
Dietary Fiber: 9g 10/10
Protein: 25g 10/10
Organic: No 4/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $4.66 4/10

12Nutritional information from https://www.kachava.com/collections/all. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $69.95 for Vanilla flavor with 15 servings per package. Accessed 10/12/20.

Per Serving13 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 9g 6.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 1g 5.0/10
Protein: 20g 9.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.53 5.5/10
Our Rating:
7.7/10
A+
See Rating Details

Arbonne ShakeRating Details

Per Serving13 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 9g 6.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 1g 5.0/10
Protein: 20g 9.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: Yes 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.53 5.5/10

13Nutrition information taken from http://www.arbonne.com/pws/homeoffice/store/amus/product/Vanilla-Protein-Shake-Mix-Powder-2070,1476,274.aspx. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $76.00 for Vanilla Protein Shake Mix with 30 servings per package. Accessed 5/19/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

#14

Plexus Lean®

Per Serving14 Our Rating
Calories: 12 5.8/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 0g 10/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.8/10
Protein: 0g 3.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.3/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.85 5.5/10
Our Rating:
7.6/10
See Rating Details

Plexus LeanRating Details

Per Serving14 Our Rating
Calories: 12 5.8/10
Sugar: 0g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 0g 10/10
Carbs: 14g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.8/10
Protein: 0g 3.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.3/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.85 5.5/10

14Nutritional information from https://plexusworldwide.com/product/plexus-lean-vanilla-whey-meal-replacement. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $39.95 for 14 Whey Vanilla Shake packets. Accessed 8/2/19.

#15

Atkins Shake®

Per Serving15 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $0.66 10/10
Our Rating:
7.3/10
A+
See Rating Details

Atkins ShakeRating Details

Per Serving15 Our Rating
Calories: 100 9.5/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 7g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 15g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $0.66 10/10

15Nutritional information from https://www.atkins.com/products/atkins-shakes/shakes/vanilla-protein-powder. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $13.98 for 15 servings of Vanilla Protein Powder. Accessed 8/2/19.

Per Serving16 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 15mg 8.5/10
Fat: 0.5g 9.5/10
Carbs: 2g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 4/10
Price: $1.30 10/10
Our Rating:
7.3/10
A
See Rating Details

Quest ProteinRating Details

Per Serving16 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 15mg 8.5/10
Fat: 0.5g 9.5/10
Carbs: 2g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 4/10
Price: $1.30 10/10

16Nutritional information from https://www.questnutrition.com/collections/protein-powders/products/us-1-6lb-protein-powder-vanilla-milkshake. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $29.99 for Vanilla Milkshake with 23 servings per package. Accessed 3/12/20.

Per Serving17 Our Rating
Calories: 180 8.5/10
Sugar: 4g 6.8/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 6.0/10
Fat: 1g 7.0/10
Carbs: 16g 6.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 6.0/10
Protein: 10g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.39 10/10
Our Rating:
7.2/10
See Rating Details

Glucerna ShakeRating Details

Per Serving17 Our Rating
Calories: 180 8.5/10
Sugar: 4g 6.8/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 6.0/10
Fat: 1g 7.0/10
Carbs: 16g 6.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 6.0/10
Protein: 10g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.39 10/10

17Glucerna can be used as a snack or meal replacement, and contains CARBSTEADY® -- a blend of slow-release carbohydrates designed to help manage blood sugar levels and reduce spikes.

Per Serving18 Our Rating
Calories: 200 5.5/10
Sugar: 3g 9.0/10
Cholesterol: 60mg 4.0/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 17g 7.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 8g 10/10
Protein: 25g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.50 7.5/10
Our Rating:
6.9/10
B-
See Rating Details

GNC Total LeanRating Details

Per Serving18 Our Rating
Calories: 200 5.5/10
Sugar: 3g 9.0/10
Cholesterol: 60mg 4.0/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 17g 7.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 8g 10/10
Protein: 25g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.50 7.5/10

18Nutrition information taken from http://www.gnc.com/total_lean/GNCTotalLeanLeanShake25.html?cgid=total_lean#start=2. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $39.99 for the Vanilla GNC | Total Lean® with 16 servings per package. Accessed 4/21/17. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

#19

Isagenix®

Per Serving19 Our Rating
Calories: 240 4.0/10
Sugar: 10g 6.0/10
Cholesterol: 50mg 5.5/10
Fat: 5g 5.0/10
Carbs: 24g 6.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 8g 10/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 10/10
Price: $4.00 5.0/10
Our Rating:
6.6/10
A+
See Rating Details

IsagenixRating Details

Per Serving19 Our Rating
Calories: 240 4.0/10
Sugar: 10g 6.0/10
Cholesterol: 50mg 5.5/10
Fat: 5g 5.0/10
Carbs: 24g 6.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 8g 10/10
Protein: 24g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 10/10
Price: $4.00 5.0/10

19Nutrition information taken from http://www.isagenix.com/~/media/product/isalean-shake/isalean-shake-fact-panels/us-en-fact-panel-isalean-shake-can-creamy-french-vanilla.pdf. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $55.99 for French Vanilla Isagenix® with 14 servings per package. Accessed 4/7/21. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

#20

Huel®

Per Serving20 Our Rating
Calories: 400 4.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 12g 4.0/10
Carbs: 42g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 9g 10/10
Protein: 29g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.75 9.0/10
Our Rating:
6.9/10
--
See Rating Details

HuelRating Details

Per Serving20 Our Rating
Calories: 400 4.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 12g 4.0/10
Carbs: 42g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 9g 10/10
Protein: 29g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $1.75 9.0/10

20Nutritional information from https://huel.com/products/huel Price per serving calculated from a package price of $29.70 for Huel Vanilla with 17 servings per package. Accessed 9/17/19.

Per Serving21 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 25mg 7.5/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 4g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 1g 5.0/10
Protein: 30g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.32 8.0/10
Our Rating:
6.7/10
B-
See Rating Details

Premier ProteinRating Details

Per Serving21 Our Rating
Calories: 160 7.0/10
Sugar: 1g 10/10
Cholesterol: 25mg 7.5/10
Fat: 3g 7.0/10
Carbs: 4g 9.5/10
Dietary Fiber: 1g 5.0/10
Protein: 30g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.32 8.0/10

21Nutritional information from https://www.premierprotein.com/products/vanilla-shake/. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $9.29 for Premier Protein Vanilla with 4 servings per package. Accessed 10/7/19.

Per Serving22 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 7g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 13g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 7.0/10
Protein: 14g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.79 7.0/10
Our Rating:
6.7/10
A+
See Rating Details

Medifast ShakeRating Details

Per Serving22 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 7g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 13g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 7.0/10
Protein: 14g 7.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.79 7.0/10

22Nutritional information from http://www.medifast1.com/Products/medifast-diet-plans/meals/shakes/prd~52500.jsp. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $19.50 for French Vanilla Shake with 7 servings per package. Accessed 5/22/17. Controversial Ingredients: Fructose, Acesulfame Potassium, and Carrageenan. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving23 Our Rating
Calories: 90 10/10
Sugar: 9g 6.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 13g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 9g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: Varies 4.0/10
Our Rating:
6.3/10
A
See Rating Details

Herbalife ShakeRating Details

Per Serving23 Our Rating
Calories: 90 10/10
Sugar: 9g 6.5/10
Cholesterol: 0mg 10/10
Fat: 1g 9.0/10
Carbs: 13g 8.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 3g 6.5/10
Protein: 9g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: Varies 4.0/10

23Nutrition information taken from http://az31823.vo.msecnd.net/content/en-us/pdf/catalog/1213_formula1_nongm_vanilla_label_us.pdf. Price per serving for Vanilla Herbalife® varies depending on distributor, not sold online. Accessed 3/1/17. Controversial Ingredients: Fructose and Carrageenan. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving24 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 11g 6.0/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 3.5g 6.5/10
Carbs: 18g 7.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 7.0/10
Protein: 2g 4.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $1.24 10/10
Our Rating:
6.3/10
B+
See Rating Details

SlimFast ShakeRating Details

Per Serving24 Our Rating
Calories: 110 9.0/10
Sugar: 11g 6.0/10
Cholesterol: 5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 3.5g 6.5/10
Carbs: 18g 7.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 4g 7.0/10
Protein: 2g 4.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $1.24 10/10

24Nutritional information from https://slimfast.com/original/#shake-mixes. Accessed 5/19/17. Controversial Ingredients: Maltodextrin, Acesulfame Potassium, Aspartame, and Carrageenan. BBB Rating accessed 1/24/19.

Per Serving25 Our Rating
Calories: 180 10/10
Sugar: 15g 4.8/10
Cholesterol: 3mg 8.5/10
Fat: 1g 8.0/10
Carbs: 15g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0.5g 4.8/10
Protein: 27g 8.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.79 8.5/10
Our Rating:
6.0/10
See Rating Details

Almased ShakeRating Details

Per Serving25 Our Rating
Calories: 180 10/10
Sugar: 15g 4.8/10
Cholesterol: 3mg 8.5/10
Fat: 1g 8.0/10
Carbs: 15g 10/10
Dietary Fiber: 0.5g 4.8/10
Protein: 27g 8.5/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 10/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: No 10/10
Price: $2.79 8.5/10

25Nutritional information from https://www.almased.com/meal-replacement-shakes. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $27.98 for Almased with 10 servings per package. Accessed 8/2/19. BBB Rating accessed 10/16/2013.

#26

Ensure Shake®

Per Serving26 Our Rating
Calories: 220 5.5/10
Sugar: 15g 4.0/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 6g 4.0/10
Carbs: 32g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 9g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $1.46 7.5/10
Our Rating:
5.5/10
C-
See Rating Details

Ensure ShakeRating Details

Per Serving26 Our Rating
Calories: 220 5.5/10
Sugar: 15g 4.0/10
Cholesterol: 4.5mg 9.5/10
Fat: 6g 4.0/10
Carbs: 32g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 0g 4.0/10
Protein: 9g 6.0/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: No 10/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $1.46 7.5/10

26Nutritional information from https://ensure.com/nutrition-products/ensure-original/vanilla-shake. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $35.00 for 24 Vanilla Shakes. Accessed 8/2/19.

#27

CTRL Shake®

Per Serving27 Our Rating
Calories: 280 4.0/10
Sugar: 6g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 110mg 4.0/10
Fat: 6g 6.0/10
Carbs: 33g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 23g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.65 7.5/10
Our Rating:
5.4/10
See Rating Details

CTRL ShakeRating Details

Per Serving27 Our Rating
Calories: 280 4.0/10
Sugar: 6g 7.5/10
Cholesterol: 110mg 4.0/10
Fat: 6g 6.0/10
Carbs: 33g 4.0/10
Dietary Fiber: 5g 8.0/10
Protein: 23g 10/10
Organic: No 4.0/10
Superfoods: No 4.0/10
Artifical Sweeteners: Yes 4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients: Yes 4.0/10
Price: $2.65 7.5/10

27Nutritional information from https://drinkctrl.com/products/cinnamon-toast. Price per serving calculated from a package price of $52.99 for CTRL Cinnamon Toast with 20 servings per package. Accessed 11/18/20.